38 Winning Designs for Superbowl Cookies That’ll Make Your Party Shine

The big game brings people together for cheers, snacks, and a healthy dose of friendly rivalry. A platter of themed cookies turns any watch party into something extra memorable while doubling as edible décor. Below are thirty-eight cookie concepts—each one playful, doable in a home kitchen, and ready to score points with fans of every team.

1. Football Field Sheet Cookies

Bake a single sheet-pan cookie, then trim the edges to form a perfect rectangle. Green royal icing sets the field, while thin white lines mark every ten yards. Mini M&M “players” pushed into soft icing finish the edible stadium.

2. Team Jersey Butter Cookies

Use a T-shirt cutter and tinted royal icing to match the colors of the competing teams. Pipe player numbers with a fine tip or simply add stripes on the sleeves. Fans will love hunting for their favorite color on the platter.

3. Playbook Chalkboard Cookies

Black cocoa powder gives the dough an almost chalkboard hue. Once the icing dries, draw routes and arrows using white edible marker or piping. The end result looks like tiny strategy boards straight from the coach’s hands.

4. Mascot Macaron Minis

French macarons might feel fancy, yet they’re perfect canvases for cartoon-style mascots. Tint shells in bold primary shades, then add eyes, beaks, or paws with buttercream. Keep designs simple so the airy cookies don’t crack under extra weight.

5. Goal Post Pretzel Cookies

Square chocolate-chip bars serve as sturdy “turf.” Insert two long pretzel sticks and a short crossbar to form the upright. A drizzle of yellow candy coating turns the structure into an unmistakable goal post.

6. Referee Striped Sandwich Cookies

Pipe alternating stripes of black and white icing across the tops to mimic referee shirts. The filling can be classic vanilla or mint for a surprise flavor. They’re a sweet nod to the officials we love to boo and cheer.

7. Foam Finger Shortbread

A hand-shaped cutter trimmed at the wrist makes the perfect outline. Bold red or blue flood icing gives that stadium-souvenir vibe. Leave space in the center for edible glitter or sprinkle designs instead of actual wording.

8. Instant Replay Camera Cookies

Shape rectangle dough pieces, then pipe darker gray lenses and buttons. A silver luster dust highlight adds a metallic gleam. They’ll have guests shouting “roll the tape” between bites.

9. Halftime Show Star Cookies

Use a star cutter and shimmery edible dust to capture concert-stage sparkle. Bright sprinkles around the edges echo confetti cannons. They’re flashy enough to rival any halftime headliner.

10. Stadium Seating Number Cookies

Flood each cookie with a single solid color to represent a stadium section. After drying, add fondant or piped numbers from 1 to 99. Mix and match hues so the platter resembles rows of seats.

11. 50-Yard Line Cutouts

Cut football-shaped ovals, then divide the surface icing into two equal fields. Pipe the number “50” front and center to mark midfield. A quick white hash mark on each side completes the look.

12. Gameday Helmet Cookies

A specialty cutter or a trimmed circle works for the outline. Royal icing builds raised face masks that dry firm. Choose colors from both conferences so every guest spots their favorite lid.

13. Pigskin Peanut Butter Cookies

The cross-hatch fork marks already evoke a grid pattern, making peanut butter dough a natural pick. Oval shaping and white-chocolate laces seal the deal. They’re chewy, salty-sweet, and unmistakably football.

14. Confetti End Zone Cookies

Flood one short edge with vibrant sprinkles to mimic end-zone celebrations. The remaining area stays a solid color so the design doesn’t overwhelm. Every bite tastes like the party after a game-winning drive.

15. Tailgate Cooler Icebox Cookies

Layer two tinted doughs, chill until firm, then slice into neat blocks. The pattern resembles retro picnic coolers. Bake straight from the fridge for sharp edges and minimal spread.

16. MVP Trophy Sugar Cookies

A simple chalice cutter creates a recognizable award silhouette. After baking, coat with light gray icing and finish with silver luster dust. Place each cookie on a stick so guests can wave their “trophies” mid-cheer.

17. Fantasy League Draft Board Cookies

Thin black lines form columns and rows across white icing. Use tiny colored candy pearls as drafted player markers. They’re a clever dessert for the stats-obsessed crowd.

18. Two-Point Conversion Double Chocolate Cookies

Cocoa-rich dough meets chocolate chips for a one-two punch. A post-bake drizzle in two contrasting chocolates underscores the “conversion.” Dense and fudgy, they deliver maximum flavor in a compact bite.

19. Overtime Clock Cookies

Circle cutters keep things classic. Pipe hash marks for minutes and bright red hands locked at zero. It’s a nail-biter visual—minus the stress.

20. Kickoff Firework Sprinkle Cookies

Start with a white icing base, then gently press sprinkles outward to form firework bursts. A quick blast of edible glitter makes them sparkle like opening-drive pyrotechnics. Each cookie feels like the game’s first big moment.

21. Snack Stadium Bar Cookies

Spread thick frosting across cooled blondie bars, then carve a smaller rectangle in the center for the field. Dots of colored icing create the illusion of packed stands. Cut into bite-size squares so everyone gets a view.

22. Coin Toss Marble Cookies

Swirl light and dark dough together without overmixing for a heads-or-tails pattern. After cooling, brush on a thin layer of edible gold. Guests can call their pick before taking a bite.

23. Touchdown Dance Gingerbread Players

Classic gingerbread dough holds its shape, lending itself to arm-raised silhouettes. Pipe bold jerseys and shoes, then add motion lines or music notes for flair. The spicy aroma matches the lively energy of a celebration dance.

24. Audible Wave Cookies

Thin stripes of varying shades replicate the look of audio waves on a screen. Drag a toothpick through wet icing to smooth transitions. They’re a clever nod to last-second play changes heard through headsets.

25. First Down Marker Biscotti Sticks

Twice-baked biscotti provide the rigid shape of those sideline poles. Orange candy coating gives vivid color, while a dab of black signals the marker head. Dunk them in coffee during early kickoffs or hot cocoa for night games.

26. Sideline Pylon Orange Cookies

Chill a sheet of dough, then cut into exact cubes before baking to reduce spread. Coat with neon-orange glaze so each block resembles a corner pylon. Stack four together for an instant edible goal-line corner.

27. Stadium Lights Lemon Bars

A simple stencil and powdered sugar form crisp rectangular “lights.” Tangy lemon curd brightens the flavor lineup. Their pale glow looks great during an evening kickoff.

28. Coach’s Whistle Shortcakes

Use an oblong cutter and add a small square spout for authenticity. After baking, coat with thinning royal icing mixed with edible silver. A black licorice lace threaded through a hole mimics the lanyard.

29. Quarterback Sneak Thumbprint Cookies

The “sneak” is the surprise caramel tucked beneath a swirl of frosting. Rich cocoa dough frames the gooey middle. They vanish from the plate as stealthily as a short-yardage play.

30. Cheer Squad Pom-Pom Coconut Cookies

Dye shredded coconut in bright colors, then press it onto warm icing. The shaggy texture looks just like mini pom-poms. They bring extra spirit to the snack table.

31. Defensive Line Cookie Pops

Attach baked circles to lollipop sticks while still warm for stability. Pipe strong jawlines and facemasks to resemble linemen. A firm candy coating keeps the pops from crumbling under pressure.

32. Instant Replay Red Flag Cookies

Cut triangles from rolled dough and bake until edges are just golden. Dust with red sanding sugar for sparkle. Toss one toward the TV when you disagree with a call—then eat it anyway.

33. Rookie Card Photo Cookies

Flood rectangles with white icing, leaving a thin border for a card look. Add printed wafer-paper photos of guests in their game-day gear, or keep them blank for doodling later. Personalization makes these sweet keepsakes.

34. Commentator’s Microphone Meringues

Stiff French meringue holds a tapered handle and rounded top. A sprinkle coating adds the look of mesh. Light as air, they won’t drown out other richer treats.

35. Snow Globe Stadium Sugar Domes

Bake hemispheres, then cut a circle from one side before cooling. Melted isomalt poured into the opening forms a transparent pane. A dusting of powdered sugar on top evokes a frosty winter game.

36. Victory Gatorade Splash Cookies

Outline the cookie in white, then allow tinted glaze to drip randomly toward the center. Choose neon orange, blue, or lemon-lime to match iconic sports drinks. The dynamic pattern looks like a post-win cooler dump.

37. Rivalry Color Block Cookies

Flood one half of the cookie, let it crust, then add the opposing side. Crisp diagonal lines keep colors from bleeding. They’re perfect for households that root for both contenders.

38. Lombardi Trophy Ice Sugar Cookies

Use a balloon cutter for the football and a rectangle beneath for the base, then attach before baking. After cooling, brush on silver high-gloss icing for a chrome effect. Holding one feels almost as good as winning the real thing.